These boots are amazing. I use the composite toe versions for work and they’re fantastic.
I wear their work boots. They last just over a year for me, which is decent given how hard I am on them. They’re the most comfortable boots I’ve tried.
My soles delaminated after a few weeks. I complained and got a replacement pair. They last about a year with moderate use, less on hard surfaces. They’re the only boots that fit me well right out of the box.
Keens are comfortable, but I stopped buying them due to durability issues. They just didn’t last.
I have the same boots in a 6-inch model. They didn’t even last a year before the heel holes and sole detachment happened. I was let down, despite being tough on boots. Planning to switch to Thorogoods next since they can be resoled and are reportedly more comfortable than Redwings.