Should I expect my 320€ Gore-Tex Hanwag boots to keep my feet completely dry

Discussion
1

Hello! I recently purchased the Hanwag Tatra II GTX boots and although they fit well, I’m experiencing moisture issues. Initially, I exchanged them due to obvious water ingress. The replacement pair is better, but I still feel moisture around my toes. The insole feels slightly damp too. I’m considering asking for a refund because I expected them to be fully waterproof for the price. Am I being unreasonable

2

It’s unfortunate to hear about your experience. I’ve used the same boots for various conditions without issues. It’s possible that your boots have been stored for a while, causing the Gore-Tex to degrade. However, consider if the moisture might be sweat; Gore-Tex isn’t as breathable as advertised. If you’re unhappy, it might be worth returning them.

3

@Koa
It could indeed be sweat. Many people underestimate how much their feet sweat, especially in waterproof boots.

4

You shouldn’t settle for boots that don’t meet your needs, especially at that price point. I’ve had great experiences with Asolo 320 GTX, which have lasted through various conditions. It might be worth considering a different brand if you’re consistently having issues.

5

@Koa
Agree on trying Asolo, particularly the 520 model. They’ve never let me down in any condition, and fit is crucial. Remember, Gore-Tex’s breathability is often overstated, and regular sock changes can help manage moisture better than relying solely on the boot’s material.

6

Consider the specific conditions when you feel the moisture. Is it only during wet weather or also in dry conditions? This could help determine if it’s an issue with the boots or environmental factors like humidity affecting the Gore-Tex’s performance.

7

@Nash
The dampness occurs in moist environments and when stepping in small puddles, but not during heavy rain, which I would find more acceptable.

8

Finch said:
@Nash
The dampness occurs in moist environments and when stepping in small puddles, but not during heavy rain, which I would find more acceptable.

It sounds like the issue may be related to sweat and the ambient moisture levels. Gore-Tex only transfers moisture when it exceeds the external humidity. You might consider waterproof socks as an alternative solution.

9

@Nash
I’ll test the boots indoors and monitor if it’s indeed sweat causing the dampness. Thanks for the suggestion.

10

Finch said:
@Nash
I’ll test the boots indoors and monitor if it’s indeed sweat causing the dampness. Thanks for the suggestion.

That sounds like a good plan. Testing them indoors should help clarify whether it’s the boots or sweat.

11

Gore-Tex should keep you dry even if submerged briefly. Try submerging the boots in a basin to see if external water seeps in. If they stay dry inside, the moisture you’re feeling is likely from sweat.