Hello everyone! I’m on the lookout for high hiking boots that are both waterproof and suitable for wide feet. I’ve tried the Keen Targhee III and they were quite comfortable, but I’ve seen mixed reviews about their durability over time. Would love to hear your suggestions and experiences. Thanks in advance!
Almost every modern boot might have reviews questioning their durability. It seems boots today aren’t made as robustly as in the past. Brands and batches vary. If the Targhee III feels good, go for it, but be prepared that they might wear out after a year of heavy use.
@Journey
It’s essential to recognize that most modern boots are designed as consumables. They’re expected to last only a couple of years at best; designed to fail to ensure continuous purchases. This is why I opt for high-quality, resoleable hiking boots, particularly those made of leather, which can last over a decade with proper care.
Consider Meindl Comfort Fit boots. They use a specially designed last that provides ample space for toes. I personally use their B category Hiker and find it excellent for wider feet. They’re durable, resoleable, and built with top-notch quality. Just make sure to check their sizing advice as it tends to run larger than standard sizes.
@Kai
Are you using the Sulden or Bernina model? I’m considering replacing my Meindl Borneo 2 MFS due to increased foot width.
Tully said:
@Kai
Are you using the Sulden or Bernina model? I’m considering replacing my Meindl Borneo 2 MFS due to increased foot width.
I have the standard width B category all-leather Hiker. It’s slightly wider than typical boots and gives extra room, which is great with thick socks or swollen feet. All Comfort Fit models share similar lasts, but sizing can vary. Typically, you might size down half or a full size depending on the model, as per the specifications on their website. If you need more details or images of the boots, feel free to reach out.
If you’re concerned about durability, look at the Targhee IV. Keen has made improvements to enhance the outsole’s durability and prevent delamination. However, it’s important to accept that boots will eventually wear out.
@Oakley
These boots are good but a bit heavy. They didn’t require breaking in for me, which was great. Just note they aren’t made in Oregon.
Uma said:
@Oakley
These boots are good but a bit heavy. They didn’t require breaking in for me, which was great. Just note they aren’t made in Oregon.
True, it’s rare to find boots manufactured in North America nowadays. They are indeed heavier, but there are lighter alternatives if that’s a concern.
@Oakley
My last pair of Keens were made in 2020, and they were manufactured in Oregon at that time.
I’ve been using Keens for a long time, specifically the 11.5W size. The Targhee 3’s have been more durable than my previous Keens.
Hanwag offers several options with various forefoot widths that might suit your needs.
I’ve had a great experience with Keen Targhee IV, size 12. They’ve been durable and fit perfectly.
I recommend Lowa Renegades if you’re looking for another durable option.
I recently started using Altra Timp 5 hikers. After two hikes covering 53 km in total, they’ve been extremely comfortable.
I’ve used both Merrell and Keen for my wide feet. I’m returning to Merrell after trying Keen, as I prefer the fit of Merrell.
Amari said:
I’ve used both Merrell and Keen for my wide feet. I’m returning to Merrell after trying Keen, as I prefer the fit of Merrell.
Did you find the Keens not wide enough?
Amari said:
I’ve used both Merrell and Keen for my wide feet. I’m returning to Merrell after trying Keen, as I prefer the fit of Merrell.
Did you find the Keens not wide enough?
They were adequate, but the fit of Merrell just works better for me.
Merrell Moabs have been a great choice for me.
I’m quite happy with my Danner Lights for hikes.