I’m searching for a suitable midlayer full zip for hiking in temperatures as low as 0 F. It needs to fit over base layers and below a soft or hard shell. Can anyone using the R1 air confirm if it’s warm enough for these conditions? Appreciate any feedback.
The effectiveness of the R1 really depends on the type of shell you use as different shells have varying heat retention. Also, personal heat generation varies widely. I can’t say for certain it will be adequate for you at 0°F. Normally, I layer as follows: Smartwool all-season quarter-zip, waffle top, midweight fleece, and either an Outdoor Research Ferrosi hoodie or Beyond L6 rain jacket. At 0°F, I’m active in these layers but add a fleece when still. While I wouldn’t spend much on a fleece (finding something suitable at a thrift store usually works), the R1 should serve you well if you choose it.
@Orion
What material is your waffle top made from?
Sawyer said:
@Orion
What material is your waffle top made from?
It’s made from Polartec Power Dry, a midweight grid fleece.
Sawyer said:
@Orion
What material is your waffle top made from?
It’s made from Polartec Power Dry, a midweight grid fleece.
Thanks. I often hear about ‘waffle’ tops but wasn’t sure if they meant cotton which isn’t recommended.
@Sawyer
Yes, it’s essentially a high-quality polyester. Most grid fleeces perform similarly if they are well made.
Orion said:
@Sawyer
Yes, it’s essentially a high-quality polyester. Most grid fleeces perform similarly if they are well made.
These started as military-issue polartec midweights. They are excellent for cold weather.
@Orion
Thanks for the insight. I tried finding basic fleeces at local thrift shops, but shelves were bare. Relocated to upper Michigan from the south, I’m adapting to cold weather hiking after overcoming a long illness. My current layers include base layers from Under Armor, a well-used North Face fleece, and a rain shell. I’m also equipped with wool accessories and keen boots. Given my limited mobility as a disabled vet, my hikes are short, and I manage without extended breaks. Your suggestions are very helpful.
@Noah
Dealing with personal challenges here too, so I resonate with your situation. Your layering sounds effective for your needs. A synthetic down might be good to carry for emergencies, though. Brands like Free Country offer good quality at lower prices if you’re considering a new fleece.
It works for me, I tend to stay warm easily.
Milo said:
It works for me, I tend to stay warm easily.
I also feel warmer than most, even in cold conditions.
The R1 Air excels in its intended role. It’s warm under a shell and manages body heat effectively during activities.
Teo said:
The R1 Air excels in its intended role. It’s warm under a shell and manages body heat effectively during activities.
Thank you!
The R1 Air is consistently recognized as a top fleece for active use. Its strength lies in its breathability and insulation, making it suitable for active winter sports like snowshoeing. Despite being active, it’s wise to have an extra insulating layer for extreme cold or inactivity.
@Joss
Thanks for your advice. My outdoor activities are moderate due to my disability, but I keep my outings manageable and avoid the need for additional insulation currently.
I heat up quickly too and find the R1 is great for managing cold winds.
Sparrow said:
I heat up quickly too and find the R1 is great for managing cold winds.
Thanks for sharing your experience.
The R1 has a strong reputation for temperature regulation. Depending on weather conditions like wind chill and humidity, it generally holds up well.
Micah said:
The R1 has a strong reputation for temperature regulation. Depending on weather conditions like wind chill and humidity, it generally holds up well.
Thanks for your input. I’m adjusting to managing layers and activities to regulate my body temperature effectively in the cold climate of Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.
@Noah
Given your location, you’re likely already adapting well to the conditions. The R1 should serve your needs adequately.